Robert Johns | 13 Jan, 2025
Fact checked by Jim Markus

Gentoo isn’t Hardcore, LFS is Hardcore Linux

If you're intrigued by Linux distros, you may have heard that Gentoo was the most hardcore. Think again.

Linux From Scratch (LFS) takes the concept of control and customization to a whole new level.

But is it a rewarding journey or just an endless rabbit hole of compiling?

Let’s dive into LFS, compare it to Ubuntu, Arch, and Gentoo, and figure out if this is the ultimate learning experience or an exercise in patience.

What Is Linux From Scratch?

Ready to become a Linux master in 2025? Maybe you're ready to take the ultimate challenge and build Linux From Scratch...

But Linux From Scratch isn’t a traditional Linux distribution — it’s a detailed step-by-step guide that teaches you how to build your own Linux system from source code.

With LFS, there’s no pre-packaged installation. You manually compile everything, from the kernel to basic utilities, customizing every component along the way.

Unlike Gentoo, which provides tools like Portage to streamline the process, LFS requires you to do everything by hand.

It’s not just about installing Linux; it’s about building Linux.

This makes LFS a phenomenal educational tool, giving you an intimate understanding of how Linux systems work.

From configuring bootloaders to compiling libraries, you’ll explore every aspect of what makes Linux tick.

However, this level of control comes at a cost. LFS demands patience, meticulous attention to detail, and a willingness to embrace its steep learning curve.

It’s not for the faint-hearted or anyone looking for a quick setup.

How Does LFS Compare to Gentoo?

Gentoo shares similarities with LFS, as both require compiling software from source, but Gentoo offers tools to make the process less daunting.

Its Portage package manager automates much of the compilation process, allowing users to focus on tuning their system rather than manually managing every package.

This makes Gentoo a middle ground—ideal for users who want control and performance optimization but don’t want to compile every tool manually.

Where Gentoo shines in practicality, LFS excels in learning.

Building an LFS system teaches you not just the "how" but also the "why" behind Linux.

For those who value the educational journey above convenience, LFS offers an unmatched experience.

How Does LFS Compare to Arch Linux?

Arch Linux sits further down the spectrum of control and complexity. Like Gentoo and LFS, Arch allows you to build your system from the ground up, but it uses precompiled binaries and a streamlined installation process.

This means you get the benefits of a customizable system without the tedium of compiling everything.

Arch’s rolling release model also ensures your software is always up to date, eliminating the need for manual updates.

For developers and power users who want control without sacrificing productivity, Arch strikes a perfect balance between flexibility and convenience.

Compared to LFS, Arch is much less time-consuming. It’s for those who want a powerful, bleeding-edge system without needing to master every intricate detail of Linux.

Why Choose Ubuntu Over LFS?

At the opposite end of the spectrum lies Ubuntu. If LFS is about mastering Linux internals, Ubuntu is about simplicity and usability.

It provides a fully functional system right out of the box, with a graphical installer, precompiled software, and minimal configuration required. It’s perfect for beginners or anyone who values stability and ease of use.

Ubuntu’s long-term support (LTS) releases are especially appealing, offering reliability without constant updates.

For those who need a system that "just works," Ubuntu is the go-to choice.

Even seasoned Linux users appreciate Ubuntu’s fuss-free nature when they want to focus on getting things done rather than tweaking their OS.

If you're enthusiastic about boosting your Linux skills even further, check out the rest of our Linux Mastery articles tutorials, including:

- Kali Linux is the Default Linux Distro for Cybersecurity (Here’s Why)

- The Best Linux Distro: Is Arch Linux Better than Ubuntu?

Wrapping Up: Who Is LFS Really For?

Linux From Scratch is for the true Linux enthusiast. If you’re passionate about understanding Linux at its deepest level and don’t mind dedicating countless hours to building your system from scratch, LFS is an incredible learning experience.

It’s not just a distribution—it’s a challenge, an education, and a badge of honor for those who complete it.

For most users, however, there are more practical options. Gentoo offers extensive control with less hassle, Arch provides flexibility with precompiled convenience, and Ubuntu remains the king of accessibility and stability.

Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro, there’s a Linux distribution that fits your needs.

But for those who crave the ultimate DIY experience and want to truly master Linux, LFS is unmatched.

What do you think? Would you tackle the challenge of Linux From Scratch, or do you prefer the convenience of Ubuntu, Arch, or Gentoo?

By Robert Johns

Technical Editor for Hackr.io | 15+ Years in Python, Java, SQL, C++, C#, JavaScript, Ruby, PHP, .NET, MATLAB, HTML & CSS, and more... 10+ Years in Networking, Cloud, APIs, Linux | 5+ Years in Data Science | 2x PhDs in Structural & Blast Engineering

View all post by the author

Subscribe to our Newsletter for Articles, News, & Jobs.

I accept the Terms and Conditions.

Disclosure: Hackr.io is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

In this article

Learn More

Please login to leave comments